Order of criticizing

Dear reviewer!

The editorial office of the journal “The Oncology and radiology of Kazakhstan” asks you to give a review paper that is submitted for publication.

We ask you to make a review on the proposed or free form with obligatory coverage of the following provisions:

  • The accordance with the thematic direction of the journal;
  • The urgency of the problem;
  • The scientific novelty and/or practical significance;
  • The sufficiency and relevance of research methods;
  • The adequacy of the research material;
  • The correctness of the discussion of the obtained results;
  • The compliance of conclusions with the goals and objectives of the research study;
  • The correctness of the design;
  • The final part (choose one of the options):

    • The paper is recommended for publication;
    • the paper is recommended for publication after correction of comments;
    • it is recommended to send the manuscript for additional review;
    • the paper is not recommended for publication.

In case of a negative opinion, we ask to justify your conclusion.
In case of discrepancy of the paper to one or more criteria we ask to indicate the necessity of a revision with recommendations

The form of review
To the editorial office of the journal
«The Oncology and Radiology of Kazakhstan»

The review
To the paper (the title of the paper)
Of authors (The list of authors)

THE TEXT OF THE REVIEW
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
I, (full name) recommend (not recommend) for publication.
Information about reviewer: full name, academic degree, academic title, the organization, the position.

Contact adresses:
E-mail;
phone number. (with code of the city);
fax (with code of the city).

Signature (if necessary signature of the person certifying the signature of the reviewer) and print.